Yelp's Best Boston Ice Cream

Cookie Monstah 80 reviews Back Bay Boston, MA Bakeries, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Food Trucks “Imagine two warm red velvet cookies hugging together a huge scoop of peach ice cream freshly prepared just for you. You raise your hands to the air and accept the blessing bestowed upon you and then take a bite and enter into pure ecstasy.” Nisreen G., Boston, MA

Rancatore’s Ice Cream 90 reviews 36 Leonard St, Belmont, MA Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt “Always a tradition to get ice cream cakes there for my birthday — they are the best ever. I went on Mother's Day for the first time in years... I got a small cup of Milk Chocolate/Coconut, my mom got a medium cup of Salted Caramel/Hazelnut Creme.” Christina V., Watertown, MA

Toscanini’s Ice Cream 826 reviews 899 Main St, Cambridge, MA Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt “The menu is definitely unique and different: Hydrox Cookie, Grape Nut Raisin, Vienna Finger Cookie, Aztec Chocolate, Nocciola... The size of the brownie chunks in the B3 was generous and not too sweet, making it a perfect balance for the ice cream.” Helen L., Jamaica Plain, MA

FoMu 60 reviews Jamaica Plain 617 Centre St, Jamaica Plain, MA Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt “We were a bit apprehensive to try out vegan ice cream, but I'm now a convert... I ended up getting the chocolate brownie, as well as cherry amaretto... The mango habanero, which had a unique refreshing tropical taste with an end note of the warm spice.” Jennifer T., Boston, MA

Lizzy’s Homemade Ice Cream 132 reviews 367 Moody St, Waltham, MA Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Coffee & Tea “Locally-churned ice cream since 1995, with flavors that will have you lip-licking for life... apple pie, orange pineapple, coconut, pumpkin pie, peach, white pistachio, peanut butter cup, Colombian fudge avalanche, I could go on.” Marcy L., NORTH ATTLEBORO, MA